Brain-Training Games Make You Better at Playing Games “but not at anything anyone might care about in real life.”


Thu, Apr 11th, 2013 10:00 by capnasty NEWS

Although a lucrative multi-million dollar business, according to The New Yorker's Gareth Cook, brain-training games don't actually make you smarter. They'll improve whatever "narrow task being trained" but won't make you better "at anything anyone might care about in real life."

Over the last year, however, the idea that working-memory training has broad benefits has crumbled. One group of psychologists, lead by a team at Georgia Tech, set out to replicate the Jaeggi findings, but with more careful controls and seventeen different cognitive-skills tests. Their subjects showed no evidence whatsoever for improvement in intelligence. They also identified a pattern of methodological problems with experiments showing positive results, like poor controls and a reliance on a single measure of cognitive improvement. This failed replication was recently published in one of psychology’s top journals, and another, by a group at Case Western Reserve University, has been published since.

The recent meta-analysis, led by Monica Melby-Lervåg, of the University of Oslo, and also published in a top journal, is even more damning. Some studies are more convincing than others, because they include more subjects and show a larger effect. Melby-Lervåg’s paper laboriously accounts for this, incorporating what Jaeggi, Klingberg, and everyone else had reported. The meta-analysis found that the training isn’t doing anyone much good. If anything, the scientific literature tends to overstate effects, because teams that find nothing tend not to publish their papers. (This is known as the “filedrawer” effect.) A null result from meta-analysis, published in a top journal, sends a shudder through the spine of all but the truest of believers. In the meantime, a separate paper by some of the Georgia Tech scientists looked specifically at Cogmed’s training, which has been subjected to more scientific scrutiny than any other program. “The claims made by Cogmed,” they wrote, “are largely unsubstantiated.”



You may also be interested in:

The Sun's Magnetic Field is About to Flip
Nasa: the world will not end in 2012
Memory is a Feature of Neurons Rather Than a Function of Brain Systems
Astronomers hopeful of detecting extra-terrestrial life
"Sleep Has to Have a Basic Evolutional Function [or] it would have been eliminated."