Why People Care About Whether Beyoncé Lip-Synched Or Not Her Performance


Sun, Jan 27th, 2013 11:00 by capnasty NEWS

If you paid attention, which frankly I had not, President Obama's inauguration included Beyoncé singing the American national anthem. Reportedly, Beyoncé "may have lip-synched her performance of 'The Star-Spangled Banner' over a recording that she’d made earlier." Or maybe not. As things stand, nobody is really sure, but for some reason, everyone seems to care. The New Yorker's Sasha Weiss explains why.

This “scandal” may seem trivial (or, as one baffled Twitterer put it “ZOMG BEYONCE LIP SYNC SCANDAL!!! 48 million people on food stamps”), but the sheer number of people interested in discussing it—the story has been reported by nearly every major American news outlet—is telling. Why should it make so many people so angry to know that Beyoncé convincingly tossed her hair and widened her eyes and shimmied her head to the sound of her very own voice? If anything, her zeal for perfection does her credit and befits the grandeur of the occasion. Not to mention the fact that Beyoncé is as skilled at lip-synching as she is at everything else: it’s all part of her carefully trained, cultivated artistry.

Beyoncé’s performance makes us nervous when juxtaposed with the earnest idealism of the inauguration. It is an event that Americans rightfully take pride in: a peaceful transfer of power; a chance to re-affirm the values of openness, freedom of speech, and egalitarianism that define us; a democratic ceremony symbolically attended by all citizens. Beyoncé’s fakery, it seems, implies some larger fakery at the heart of the whole enterprise. But, of course, the ceremony is itself a performance—how else can we explain that it is through the recitation of scripted words in a ritual call-and-response that the President assumes his position of power? We don’t want to be reminded that we’re watching mere mortals who might trip on their way to the podium, stutter through the oaths of office, shiver in the cold, or worse, err in judgment and lead the country on the wrong path. These are the people we are entrusting to enact America’s timeless values? Too bad. Beyoncé reminded us.



You may also be interested in:

I was driven mad by the Chinese education system
'Tis the Season of Election Dirty Tricks: Scaring Student Voters
EuroTrash Diary
Idaho Republican: Rape an Act of God
Indiana is Like Iraq