"Omnipotence is the power to create orders, not merely the power to enforce them."

Working as an IDF Checkpoint Soldier


Wed, Jul 25th, 2012 21:00 by capnasty NEWS

The Boston Review has a lengthy but fascinating read by an Israel Defense Forces soldier, Oded Na'aman, who explains life at a West Bank checkpoint, where survival depends on knowing what others are thinking before they do.

In the West Bank, the IDF is directed neither to conquer enemy territory nor to prevent an enemy from conquest. It is engaged in "low intensity conflict," a phrase that encapsulates the indecisiveness of occupation. The enemy -- the foreign people the military is charged with subduing -- is within a territory that is already under the military's control. Since the military occupies the land on which the enemy resides, it cannot conquer the enemy's land any more than it already has. And insofar as the enemy has no land, it has no political independence, no real capacity for civic life. It is therefore impossible for Israel -- logically impossible -- to "go to war" with the Palestinians in the West Bank: Palestinian individuals may suffer to a greater or lesser degree, but the Palestinian people, as a people, cannot be further defeated.

At the same time, West Bank Palestinians are foreign to Israel. They are not Israeli citizens, and Israeli civil law does not apply to them. Israeli martial law -- the law that, at least in principle, guides and constrains the IDF -- also is not a law for the Palestinians, although it does affect their lives in profound ways. Law does not govern the relations between the State of Israel and Palestinian civilians in the West Bank. Unlike citizens, who obey the police not only because they are powerful but also because they are authoritative, Palestinians obey the orders of the IDF only because it is powerful. Military laws in the West Bank therefore are not laws at all, but merely what the legal philosopher H. L. A. Hart called "orders backed by threats": the source and limit of their authority depends on the source and limit of particular threats.



You may also be interested in:

Research Suggests that Work is Bad for Your Health, Unemployment Worse
Confessions of a Corporate Spy
The Man They Couldn't Hang
A Company With No Bosses
The Single Biggest Decision a CEO Will Make is Who They Will Name Manager