How Economics Can Save You If You Are Kidnapped by Pirates


Tue, May 15th, 2012 10:00 by capnasty NEWS

The Atlantic's Megan McArdle explains how economics can save you if you find yourself kidnapped by pirates. The number one suggestion: keep your mouth shut.

According to a hostage negotiator quoted by This American Life, giving away this information is apparently typical of hostages and is counter-productive to their release as it narrows the bid-ask spread. Economists would describe hostage negotiation as a bilateral monopoly price negotiation that is structurally just a special case of chicken. That is, unlike a barrel of oil or a freight car full of soybeans which can trade on an extremely liquid market with innumerable buyers and sellers, a hostage has exactly one seller (the kidnappers) and exactly one buyer (the employer and/or family of the hostage). When there is only one buyer, the opportunity cost for ransoming the hostage is zero. Likewise, the employer and/or family has no realistic alternative means to recover the hostage. In order for everybody to walk away happy, we need a cooperate-cooperate outcome: the kidnapper has to give up the hostage and the employer/family has to give up a ransom. This structure also characterizes art theft, which in practice is not a matter of fencing art on the black market but ransoming art to a museum's insurance company.



You may also be interested in:

Growthism: Capitalism for the Poor, Socialism for the Rich
Sony Makes More Money Selling Insurance Than It Does With Electronics
Maltese Citizenships Now on Sale
“The revelations may embarrass Justin Trudeau, who has campaigned against tax havens.”
Snowden's Revelations Hurting the Profits of American Tech Companies