While "we just don't know enough" when it comes to gene editing to create designer babies, bioethicist Ronald Green of Dartmouth College in New Hampshire believes "it is unavoidably in our future." If anything, considering the risks of not knowing what "serious errors" could happen from editing our genome, embryo selection may a more viable alternative for what that's worth.
There are thousands of mostly rare and nasty genetic diseases that can be pinpointed to a specific gene mutation. Most more common diseases or medical predispositions – for example, diabetes, heart disease or certain types of cancer – are linked to several or even many genes, can’t be predicted with any certainty, and depend also on environmental factors such as diet.
When it comes to more complex things like personality and intelligence, we know very little. Even if they are strongly inheritable – it’s estimated that up to 80% of intelligence, as measured by IQ, is inherited – we don’t know much at all about which genes are involved, and not for want of looking.
At best, Greely says, PGD might tell a prospective parent things like “there’s a 60% chance of this child getting in the top half at school, or a 13% chance of being in the top 10%”. That’s not much use.
|Human Killing Virus Fun!|
|The Girl Who Turned to Bone: "how medically relevant rare diseases can be"|
|How Toilet Paper is Made|
|Stroke Turns Man Gay|
|Whole, Functional Organ Grown from Scratch|
|“A company headquartered in Toronto runs a successful affordable mobile phone service in the US.”|
|“Inhibiting this pathway has extended life span in every species studies to date.”|
|Japanese Robot Serves Ice Cream From Inside a Vending Machine|
|“Civilisation is a movement, and not a condition, a voyage and not a harbour.”|
|Why, Typewriters Are Alive and Well, Thank you|
|Somebody Needs to Build a New Facebook Stat|
|The (Very Scary) People of Public Transit|
|“Prof Mallett has wanted to build a time machine for most of his life.”|
|How to Avoid Jury Duty|
|CaptchaTweet: Write Tweets in Captcha Form|
|“Artificial intelligence can detect your sexuality and politics just by looking at your face.”|
|“Forget everything you were taught about having your phone out at the table — you'll need it to call the robots that serve you.”|