While the issues of ethics with autonomous cars are nothing new, now that Google's self-driving car is tackling cities, a new question has come up: should a self-driving car faced with no other option but to crash into something (or someone), collide with the object that will cause the least amount of harm overall?
In the name of crash-optimization, you should program the car to crash into whatever can best survive the collision. In the last scenario, that meant smashing into the Volvo SUV. Here, it means striking the motorcyclist who’s wearing a helmet. A good algorithm would account for the much-higher statistical odds that the biker without a helmet would die, and surely killing someone is one of the worst things auto manufacturers desperately want to avoid.
But we can quickly see the injustice of this choice, as reasonable as it may be from a crash-optimization standpoint. By deliberately crashing into that motorcyclist, we are in effect penalizing him or her for being responsible, for wearing a helmet. Meanwhile, we are giving the other motorcyclist a free pass, even though that person is much less responsible for not wearing a helmet, which is illegal in most U.S. states.
Not only does this discrimination seem unethical, but it could also be bad policy. That crash-optimization design may encourage some motorcyclists to not wear helmets, in order to not stand out as favored targets of autonomous cars, especially if those cars become more prevalent on the road. Likewise, in the previous scenario, sales of automotive brands known for safety may suffer, such as Volvo and Mercedes Benz, if customers want to avoid being the robot car’s target of choice.
|"Imagine a scenario in which the mass adoption of Uber leads to a potential death spiral for public transit."|
|How Julie Koepcke Survived an Airplane Crash|
|Mount Everest Is So Crowded, You Have to Line Up to Reach the Top|
|Google Maps Shows You Where You'd End Up if you Tunneled Accross the Earth|
|The Firefly: Geospace Studios All-Weather, Illuminated, Human-Powered Vehicle|
|“Astronomers have sent a radio message to a neighbouring star system.”|
|“When automation starts displacing lawyers, accountants and bankers, then we might see some push-back.”|
|“A photograph of the last male northern white rhinoceros.”|
|How to Avoid Jury Duty|
|CaptchaTweet: Write Tweets in Captcha Form|
|“A fraudster poses as an attractive woman and encourages a man to masturbate in front of a webcam.”|
|Japanese Robot Serves Ice Cream From Inside a Vending Machine|
|“Semis, not personal cars, are the smartest use of autonomous technology.”|
|“Facebook has contributed to, and profited from, the erosion of democratic norms in the United States.”|
|“The homemade airplane does indeed fly!”|
|Short Story of Similar Objects|
|“The company’s ambition, its ruthlessness, and its lack of a moral compass scare me.”|