Brian Martin, from Science, Technology and Society at the University of Wollongong, Australia, argues, in this paper published in Philosophy and Social Action, against intellectual property. Mr. Martin says that "the usual arguments for intellectual property do not hold up under scrutiny," and that "the metaphor of the marketplace of ideas provides no justification for ownership of ideas."
Copyright is one of four main types of intellectual property or, in other words, ownership of information. The others are patents, trademarks and trade secrets. Copyright covers the expression of ideas such as in writing, music and pictures. Patents cover inventions, such as designs for objects or industrial processes. Trademarks are symbols associated with a good, service or company. Trade secrets cover confidential business information.
The type of property that is familiar to most people is physical objects. People own clothes, cars, houses and land. When people own ideas, this is called intellectual property. But there has always been a big problem with owning ideas - exclusive use or control of ideas doesn't make nearly as much sense as it does applied to physical objects.
Many physical objects can only be used by one person at a time. If one person wears a pair of shoes, no one else can wear them at the same time. (The person who wears them often also owns them, but not always.) This is not true of intellectual property. Ideas can be copied over and over, but the person who had the original copy still has full use of it. Suppose you write a poem. Even if a million other people have copies and read the poem, you can still read the poem yourself. In other words, more than one person can use an idea - a poem, a mathematical formula, a tune - without reducing other people's use of the idea. Shoes and poems are fundamentally different in this respect.
|#DearRobFord by @DearRobFord #VoteTO|
|Everything I Need to Know About Morality I Learned From Star Trek|
|That's Mister Fuck the Drug War to You|
|"Spies do not give their material to newspapers."|
|Caught in the Storm, Penned in at Queen Street #G20|
|3D Printed $10,000 House|
|“Facebook played a 'determining role' in stirring up hatred against Rohingya Muslims.”|
|“The Pentagon’s relatively quiet tip-toe into converting the U.S. Armed Forces to a machine-majority force.”|
|Future Horizon's Plasma Lightsabers|
|CaptchaTweet: Write Tweets in Captcha Form|
|Japanese Robot Serves Ice Cream From Inside a Vending Machine|
|“New green policies so hard-hitting and extensive they can be felt across the world.”|
|“Clearly, no one is going to build weapons that have sufficient general intelligence to, for example, decide and execute a plan to take over the world.”|
|“Contains all the same components as cow’s milk, [...] but doesn’t use any animals in its production process.”|
|The (Very Scary) People of Public Transit|
|“Amazon Paid No Federal Taxes In 2017.”|
|“Traditional path to economic growth may close to all but a handful of developing countries.”|